By Yutaka Niihara
By focusing on how best to help patients, researchers can sometimes find solutions that are much simpler than anticipated. That has been the guiding approach to our efforts to develop a treatment for sickle cell disease.
Sickle cell disease is a devastating hereditary condition afflicting millions of people, particularly in West and Central Africa as well as those of African descent in the United States and South America.
The disease involves normally round soft red blood cells being deformed into a rigid form.
This change brings severe pain, life threatening infections and organ damage.
In some parts of central Africa, as many as one person in 50 is born with the disease; about 90 percent of them die by the age of five and 99 percent by the age of 20.
About 4 million people in West and Central Africa suffer from the disease; from 500,000 to 1 million people in South America and about 100,000 people in the United States, where about one in 500 African American children are born with the condition.
People with only one copy of the sickle cell gene are said to have sickle cell trait, which in some cases may cause far milder symptoms.
Sickle cells die faster than normal red blood cells, and the body cannot replace them fast enough, leading to anemia.
Normal red blood cells live for about 120 days before they are replaced with new ones. Sickle-shaped cells are destroyed in about 16 to 21 days.
In addition, sickled red blood cells tend to clump together and stick to the arterial walls, blocking blood flow and leading to pain, sores and organ failure.
Red blood cells contain the protein hemoglobin, which transports oxygen to other body tissues.
Normal red blood cells contain hemoglobin A and remain round and smooth when oxygen is released.
In contrast, the bone marrow of people with sickle cell disease produces red blood cells with a different form, hemoglobin S, which stands for sickle.
As these cells release oxygen, instead of remaining smooth and flexible, they become rigid, inflexible and sticky.
The complications of sickle cell disease occur when these rigid red blood cells block veins, causing pain in the arms, legs, back and stomach, bones, skin and other parts of the body. Tissue that does not receive normal blood flow eventually becomes damaged.
There are several types of sickle cell disease. The most common are sickle cell anemia, sickle-hemoglobin C disease, sickle β0thalassemia and sickle β+ thalassemia.
Sickle hemoglobin C is a form of sickle cell disease characterized by the presence of two abnormal types of hemoglobin, S and C.
Sickle β0 and β+ thalassemia are forms of sickle cell disease characterized by the presence of hemoglobin S and β thalassemia. Those patients all experience anemia as well as painful crises and have an increased risk of infection. (1)
People with sickle cell trait usually show no symptoms, but can experience limitations with heavy physical exertion.
Sickle Cell Treatments
Currently there is no universal cure for sickle cell disease. Treatments primarily include pain medication and hydration, hydroxyurea, which decreases the incidence of painful crises but is often not well tolerated, and bone marrow transplant, which is costly and has limited availability.
The cost of treating sickle cell disease exceeds an estimated $1.1 billion annually in the United States alone, according to a study released in 2009. (2)
The average annual cost per patient was $10,704 for children 9 and under and $34,266 for adults 30 to 39 years old.
Over the years, thousands of medications have been proposed for treating sickle cell disease, but most of them were eliminated at the pre-clinical level.
Only about 80 medications have actually entered into clinical trials, and only three have made it into Phase III trials.
Our Research Approach
Our approach has been very different from that of other researchers. Many scientists have been looking to treat or cure sickle cell disease from the genetic perspective.
However, sickle cell gene therapy remains very difficult and may take many more years of research. In the meantime, patients are still suffering.
Our goal has been to find an effective means to control the symptoms in a manner roughly analogous to diabetic medications for treating diabetes.
It is an approach suggested by my mentor, Dr. Charles R. Zerez. To do so, we began by studying the dynamics of sickle cells.
A study led by Dr. Zerez in the late 1980s showed that red blood cells from individuals with sickle cell disease are more susceptible to oxidation damage. (3)
That line of reasoning led us to look at anti-oxidants. Red blood cells have their own anti-oxidant, a nucleic acid called NAD (nicotinamide adenosine dinucleotide).
NAD plays a key role in cell metabolism and can be used to gauge oxidant stress in red blood cells by what is known as NAD redox potential. (In order to calculate the NAD redox potential, we measure the concentration of oxidized NAD (NAD+), reduced NAD (NADH), and total NAD.)
The research by Dr. Zerez showed that sickle red blood cells tend to have a decreased NAD redox potential compared with normal cells. At the same time, sickle cells have an increased rate of NAD synthesis. This was interpreted as a means by the cells to compensate for increased oxidant stress.
One of the ways that we decided to approach this was to give sickle red blood cells more raw materials to produce these anti-oxidants. Sickle cells demonstrated tendency to draw in these raw materials very rapidly.
Then, with the additional raw materials, they had increase in the formulation of the anti-oxidant NAD.
An in-vitro study in the 1990s demonstrated the evidence for increased transport and utilization in sickle cells of glutamine, a common amino acid that is a precursor for NAD. (4)
Glutamine has been shown to play an important role in the redox status of sickle red blood cells, which were taking in glutamine at an unusually high rate. The evidence suggests that glutamine is used in sickle cells to produce the anti-oxidant molecule NAD.
Our research has since focused on using L-glutamine, an inexpensive compound widely consumed as part of a normal diet or as a dietary supplement.
L-Glutamine and the NAD Redox Potential
Our observation was that orally administered L-glutamine increased the NAD redox potential of sickle red blood cells, making them much healthier.
An in-vivo study in the late 1990s showed that oral L-glutamine could significantly increase the NAD redox potential in sickle red blood cells, which may decrease the oxidative susceptibility. (5)
Among patients treated with L-glutamine in the study, there were subjective reports of improvements in regards to chronic pain and energy levels.
In sickle cell disease, many of the complications and much of the suffering can be linked to the tendency of sickle red blood cells to stick to the endothelial cells that make up the inner lining of the blood vessels.
This slows the travel of the red blood cells through capillaries, which often leads to blockages, or vasoocclusion. This blockage causes pain, inflammation and organ failure.
Finding a means of reducing this adhesion to the vascular endothelium has been an important goal of our research. L-glutamine has been shown to reduce the adhesion of sickle red blood cells in human umbilical vein endothelial cells, suggesting a positive physiological effect for L-glutamine in the disease. (6)
In addition, sickle cell anemia patients may experience significantly reduced physical abilities. L-glutamine has been shown to have another positive impact in sickle cell anemia patients by improving their exercise endurance. (7)
L-Glutamine Clinical Trials
With grants from the FDA and the National Institute of Health, we were able to move forward into Phase II trials, which completed in 2008. The 57-week, randomized, double-blind clinical study was completed by 30 patients at five sites.
The Phase II trials demonstrated a major trend toward a reduced frequency of painful sickle cell crises for the treatment group. In addition, the frequency of hospitalizations decreased significantly.
The subjects in the placebo group experienced painful sickle cell crises at 30 percent to 149 percent higher frequency than the L-glutamine group. The hospitalization rate among the placebo group was 31 percent to 52 percent higher as well.
Anecdotally, chronic skin ulcers healed in three patients receiving L-glutamine, while none in the placebo group had such changes.
No major side effects were noted, nor were there any deaths or severe adverse events attributable to the L-glutamine treatment.
At the conclusion of the Phase II trials, we met with the FDA for the “End of Phase II meeting.” During that meeting, we were authorized to move forward to the Phase III trial with a larger enrollment than that of the Phase II.
Enrollment in the Phase III trial began in 2010, and the study is expected to be completed in the year 2013. The 57-week clinical study involves about 225 patients at 30 sites across the United States.
Most of the patients are of African descent, although there are some Hispanics involved also.
Two-thirds of the patients are receiving L-glutamine and one-third a placebo.
The study data will be reviewed and analyzed by various committees; then the results will be submitted to the FDA. The FDA has granted fast track status to this project, meaning the agency is obligated to give a response within six months of the receipt of the data.
L-glutamine therapy has also received orphan drug status from the FDA in 1997. Furthermore, more recently, it has received a positive opinion from the European Medicines Agency on European Orphan Drug Status.
Orphan drug status confers seven years of marketing exclusivity after the approval of the medication in the United States and 10 years in EU member countries.
Also, it provides a streamlined regulatory review process and fee reductions. We are hopeful that this process will enable us to obtain FDA approval by late 2013 or early 2014.
Sickle cell disease causes a great deal of suffering for millions of people, particularly the young. We were convinced from an early point in our research that this treatment could make a substantial difference in the lives of sickle cell patients.
An early challenge in our research was convincing people that a treatment as simple as oral L-glutamine therapy could help patients. While a genetic cure may one day be found, soon we hope to be able to begin to alleviate the suffering that patients are experiencing today.
About Yutaka Niihara
Yutaka Niihara, MD, MPH, is Chief Executive Officer of specialty pharmaceutical company Emmaus Medical Inc. and principal inventor of the patented L-glutamine therapy for the treatment of sickle cell disease.
Dr. Niihara is a Clinical Professor of Medicine, Division of Medical Oncology/Hematology at David Geffen School of Medicine at UCLA.
- Sickle Cell Disease and Sickle Cell Trait, Hemoglobin Sickle C Disease, Sickle Beta Zero Thalassemia, Sickle Beta+ Thalassemia Texas Department of State Health Services, See http://www.dshs.state.tx.us/newborn/celltrai.shtm
- Kauf, T et al: The cost of health care for children and adults with sickle cell disease. American Journal of Hematology (June) 2009. 323-327. See http://cellods.com/SCD_Cost_Study.pdf
- Zerez, CR et al: Decreased Erythrocyte Nicotinamide Redox Potential and Abnormal Pyridine Nucleotide Content in SCD. Blood Vol 71, No 2 (February). 1988:512-515
- Niihara, Y et al: Increased red cell glutamine availability in sickle cell anemia: Demonstration of increased active transport, affinity, and increased glutamate level in intact red cells J Lab Clin Med 1997; 130:83-90
- Niihara, Y et al: Oral L-glutamine therapy for sickle cell anemia: I. Subjective clinical improvement and favorable change in red cell NAD redox potential. Am J Hem. 1998; 58:117-121
- Niihara, Y et al: L-glutamine therapy reduces endothelial adhesion of sickle red blood cells to human umbilical vein endothelial cells. BMC Blood Disorders 2005;5:4
- Macan, HR et al; L-glutamine therapy Improves Minute Ventilation of Sickle Cell Anemia Patients. Blood Vol110, No.11 Nov.16, 2007 p.138